I finally tried Spotify and YouTube Music to see if they could pull me away from my Apple Music subscription — here's what I think of the three streaming services.
I have been streaming music since it became available here in Canada, and for the first few years of the streaming revolution, that meant I was using Songza. We didn't have Pandora or Spotify in the early years, and Apple Music wasn't around yet. Eventually, Songza got bought out by Google and then changed into Google Play Music, which I didn't like, so I went looking for a change. While Spotify was around Canada by that point, Apple Music was just about to launch. Once Apple Music launched, I signed up and never looked back. I was happy to throw my $10 a month at Apple for streaming all the music I could, but I never even checked out the main competition, until now.
I have spent the last few months testing out Spotify and YouTube Music to finally decide which streaming service is right for me, and here's what I have found.
Music library, audio quality, and device limitations
Now, I'm not a total audiophile, but I do want my music to sound good and the good news is, regardless of which option you choose, your music will sound great. Spotify can stream up to 320 kbps via Spotify Premium's "Extreme" audio quality option, whereas both Apple Music and YouTube Music only go up to 256 kbps. Unless you are listening on some sort of high-end audio system or high-end headphones, chances are you won't be able to tell the difference in streaming quality.
When it comes to the music library, each service offers a pretty extensive catalog. Apple Music is said to have about 60 million songs. In contrast, Spotify is said to have about 50 million, and YouTube Music says it has 50 million official songs — but that's just the tip of the iceberg with YouTube Music.
Unofficial music on YouTube Music
On top of official singles and albums from record labels, YouTube Music has a ton of mashups, fan-created covers, live videos, remixes, and more, making the selection of music much larger than the official music the service boasts. Apple Music and Spotify are more or less limited to official releases from record labels or artists, whereas YouTube Music has almost every bit of Music ever uploaded to YouTube in some fashion. It does make YouTube Music standout for people who love diving into that kind of content.
It's a bit of a double edge sword though because some of that content (especially the fan-created stuff) will get taken down sometimes, so it's a bit of a gamble to rely on it; however, in the couple months, I have used YouTube Music a lot of my favorite fan-created content has stayed in place.
Lastly, when it comes to device limitations, Apple Music has the most. While there is technically an Android version of Apple Music, frankly, it's awful and not worth using — meaning you need an Apple device to enjoy Apple Music.
Spotify, on the other hand, is available for iOS, Android, some smart TVs, even gaming consoles, making it the easiest to use everywhere you could want.
YouTube Music only has an iOS and Android app, but it does have a web player, meaning you should be able to access it on any browser.
Recommendations and music discovery
A huge draw of streaming music is getting recommendations of new artists or genres to listen to, and all three services offer playlists, radio stations, and song suggestions based on your listening habits. When it comes to new music recommendations, people live and die by either Spotify or Apple Music, having better recommendations, and ultimately it comes down to personal preference.
As someone who has used Apple Music for four years, my Apple Music recommendations are spot on because the service knows what I like and what I don't. So, while I think Apple Music has perfect recommendations, both Spotify and YouTube Music are pretty good.
In the months I have used Spotify and YouTube Music, Spotify has seemed to pick up on my taste in music quicker. I felt like after about three weeks of using Spotify, the service was recommending some amazing stuff from artists and had never heard of before, and I was digging it.
YouTube Music took a bit longer and is still a little hit and miss from time to time. The YouTube Music algorithm, much like YouTube, seems to take in outside factors about what's trending or what's popular more so than Spotify and Apple Music.
That being said, all three services will eventually learn what you like and what you don't and be able to give you reliable recommendations.
I won't bury the lede on this section; Spotify wins hands down. I was blown away by how smooth the entire app experience is and every aspect seems to work flawlessly. Adding music to a playlist, setting up a queue of music to play next, and every sharing music on social media is all so simple from Spotify. It's easy to see why Spotify is so beloved by its users because the experience is just so smooth and seamless — it's hard not to love it.
As much as it pains me to say, Apple Music still has weird quirks and glitches that pop up all the time for me. It boggles my mind that Apple Music still has simple issues four years after launching the service. Adding music to the queue is annoying as hell in Apple Music, half the time when I try to add a song to the queue to play next it doesn't work. Disliking and loving music can be frustrating on iOS as well, often not registering when you try, which sucks because that's how you get Apple Music to recommend you the good stuff.
Lastly, the YouTube Music app is fine. It's not stellar in any way, but also has no glaring errors. It is the newest service and the interface has gotten better since its launch, but it still just receives a passing grade.
Both Spotify and YouTube Music have free ad-supported versions of their service, whereas Apple Music does not, meaning if you really don't want to pay, Apple Music won't be for you. Of course, both Spotify and YouTube Music have some pretty hefty limitations on their free version, the biggest of which coming from YouTube music. If you want to use YouTube Music in the background on your phone, you need to pay for it, which kind of makes the free version useless for most people.
Spotify clocks in at $9.99 a month for a single user, which matches both Apple Music an YouTube Music, and all three services have family plans for $14.99 as well. Plus, the Spotify student play is $4.99 and includes an ad-supported tier of Hulu, which is a nice touch, and Apple Music also has a student plan for $4.99.
YouTube Music has no student plan but does offer YouTube Premium for $11.99 a month, which includes everything you get in YouTube Music, plus a bunch of perks for regular YouTube. This like YouTube Originals, add-free videos, playing videos and music in the background, and a few more features. It's pretty smart because if you're paying $9.99 for YouTube Music already, the extra $2 a month for additional perks is pretty enticing.
All three services have their perks and downfalls, so it's hard to pick a winner. In the end, I have decided to stay with Apple Music, mainly because I'm pretty entrenched in the Apple ecosystem. If you're an Apple user and have a ton of Apple devices, Apple Music is likely a bit better for you. Being able to use Siri to control your music is great, and having all your playlists, music selections, and everything else synced across devices is great.
That being said, if you're brand new to streaming and looking to make the dive into service for the first time, I would recommend Spotify. The app is beautifully designed and makes everything so simple. Sharing music with your friends, creating playlists, and music discovery has never been made more simple.
Lastly, don't discount YouTube Music if you're a YouTube fan — the service is the newest and it's getting better all the time. It stands out when it comes to a variety of content because it can offer unique remixes and fan-created content you can't find anywhere else. If you already use YouTube a lot, YouTube Music will likely fit your life pretty well.
Apple Music has incredible recommendations and offers more editorial content based on music than the other services do and it's seamlessly integrated into iOS, macOS, watchOS, and tvOS. It has a student plan for students, plus individual and family plans to fit your life and needs.
With an incredible app experience, a huge music library, and the ability to play songs at a higher quality, Spotify checks all the boxes for casual users, music fans, and audiophiles alike. Plus, with student, individual, and family plans, and even a free ad-supported option, it's easy to modify your subscription to fit your situation.
YouTube Music may be the newest service to the party, but its learning quickly. On top of all the official music it offers, you can also find remixes, fan-created content, and mashups you won't find anywhere else. The app experience isn't stellar, but if you use YouTube a lot already, YouTube Music offers a lot of perks.